ComebackTown giving voice to the people of Birmingham & Alabama.
Click here to sign up for newsletter. (Opt out at any time)
Most folks’ first impression of Birmingham won’t be from driving to town on I-65.
Nor arriving at our Amtrak station, or at the Birmingham-Shuttlesworth International Airport.
It will likely be from a simple Google search.
A Google search of Birmingham, however, can be quite embarrassing.
A business friend of mine was recently recruiting a manager for his fast growing company.
He identified a solid out-of-state candidate, but needed to sell him and his family on Birmingham.
The candidate was excited about the opportunity until his thirteen year old son Googled Birmingham and was able to convince his parents that Birmingham was not a good option.
I thought the story a bit farfetched until I Googled Birmingham.
Here’s what I found…
I even found a site that claimed Birmingham was the worst city in the U.S.
Don’t get me wrong, there is plenty positive about Birmingham on the Internet, but much of the negative is because of how Birmingham is measured against other cities.
Rankings between Birmingham and other cities are flawed
Birmingham is one of 35 municipalities in Jefferson County.
Therefore the City of Birmingham is ONLY the City of Birmingham. Birmingham does NOT include the other 34 municipalities in Jefferson County.
Nashville, Tennessee, on the other hand, has a combined city-county government with Davidson County–so when Birmingham and Nashville are compared, the comparison is the City of Birmingham without its suburbs vs. Nashville which includes all of Davidson County with its upscale neighborhoods.
The same is true when Birmingham is compared to other city-county governments such as…
Jacksonville/Duvall County, Florida
Louisville/Jefferson County, Kentucky
Indianapolis/Marion County, Indiana
So when someone Googles ‘crime’, Birmingham’s statistics do not include low crime numbers from Mountain Brook, Vestavia Hills, Trussville, or Homewood. This inflates Birmingham’s crime ranking and tells the world that Birmingham is dangerous.
If the City of Birmingham’s crime statistics were ranked strictly against the core urban areas of these other cities, Birmingham wouldn’t look as dangerous. And believe me, these other cities have areas that are unsafe.
I’m not making light of the city of Birmingham’s murder rate–which is horrendous–but violent crime has exploded in urban areas all over the U.S. According to FBI Director Christopher Wray, “In 2020 there was a 29% jump in murders in the United States.”
And it’s not just crime.
When one compares obesity, poverty, or education in Birmingham without its upscale neighborhoods, Birmingham naturally ranks poorly.
Birmingham–the second largest city in the state
Google ‘Birmingham’ and you’ll see that Birmingham is ranked the second largest city in the state behind Huntsville.
According to U.S. Census, Huntsville has a population of 215,006–Birmingham 200,733.
However, Jefferson County has a population of 674,721.
If Birmingham had a county-city government, its population would be Jefferson County which has a population three times greater than Huntsville. And even if Huntsville merged with Madison County, which has a population of 388,153, Birmingham would be almost twice as large.
By the way, this is the reason Louisville merged with Jefferson County, Kentucky in 2003.
When Lexington, the second largest city in the state, created a county-city government with Fayette County, Louisville became at risk of becoming the second largest city in Kentucky.
Louisville merged with Jefferson County and remains the largest city in the state. Louisville 782,969 to Lexington 322,570.
Birmingham–the worst city in the U.S.
Then my Google search got really ugly.
I found a video titled the, “TOP 10 reasons why BIRMINGHAM, ALABAMA is the WORST city in the US.”
Its description of Birmingham is horrifying.
Birmingham super bugs crawl all over you inside or outside your house.
Violent crimes committed even in your own home.
Risk of being a social outcast for telling someone you’re an Alabama football fan.
Most of the video is pure nonsense, but it has thousands of page views. (I’m not including the link because I don’t want to increase the number of clicks). Google it if you’re inclined.
Birmingham great quality of life
Birmingham is a wonderful place to live and raise a family.
But when folks from out-of-state Google Birmingham, they don’t get a true picture.
A Google search of Birmingham hurts in recruiting families and businesses.
I’m not suggesting we combine our municipalities into Jefferson County, but being separate has unintended consequences.
David Sher is the founder and publisher of ComebackTown. He’s past Chairman of the Birmingham Regional Chamber of Commerce (BBA), Operation New Birmingham (REV Birmingham), and the City Action Partnership (CAP).
Click here to sign up for our newsletter. (Opt out at any time)
social experiment by Livio Acerbo #greengroundit – original source here