Hanes: It’s not too late for politicians to do the right thing for anglo youth | Montreal Gazette

Breadcrumb Trail Links

Opinion
Columnists

The mandate for anglophone CEGEP students to take three core courses in French was never supposed to be included in Bill 96. What urgency is there now, other than petty partisanship?

Quebec Liberal Leader Dominique Anglade speaks with students at Dawson College in February 2022. The Liberals have a duty to try to clean up the mess they helped create with a Bill 96 amendment affecting anglophone CEGEP students, Allison Hanes writes. Photo by Allen McInnis /Montreal Gazette

Article content

Young English-speaking Quebecers are watching their futures flash before their eyes as leaders play political games at their expense.

Article content

The clause-by-clause study of Bill 96, the legislation to strengthen the French language, has presented enticing opportunities to limit the rights of Quebec’s English community even more. Perhaps no amendment is more serious than the suddenly sprung stipulation that English-speaking CEGEP students take three non-language courses in French in order to graduate.

Unanimously endorsed without notice or consultation, this ill-considered change could throw the higher-education hopes of many anglophone youth into disarray. Some would certainly manage, but others would struggle, undermining their dreams, plans and life prospects.

How it even came into being is a chronicle of a political fiasco. Simon Jolin-Barrette, Quebec’s minister for the French language, initially suggested the clause only apply to francophone and allophone students attending English CEGEPs. But Liberal language critic Hélène David inexplicably said there should be no exemption for anglophones. Hardly believing his ears, Jolin-Barrette gleefully pounced on the opportunity, as did Québec solidaire and the Parti Québécois (which wants to see Bill 101 cover CEGEPs anyway).

Article content

But educators caught off-guard by this back-of-the-napkin curriculum change have denounced it as an unrealistic expectation that will upend the administration of English CEGEPs already reeling from enrolment freezes imposed under Bill 96. They argue it will also doom to failure a proportion of anglophone students who might not be able to pass college-level core courses in French — or at least not with strong enough marks to get them into competitive university programs.

Meanwhile, scores of young anglophones and their parents fear the fallout from this unfair, unworkable, counterproductive amendment, which could kick in as early as next year.

Much of their anger has been directed at the Quebec Liberal Party over its perceived betrayal. Facing a furious backlash — and plummeting support — the Liberals recognized their mistake and went tail between legs to Premier François Legault to try to rectify matters.

Article content

This climbdown is embarrassing for Liberal Leader Dominique Anglade, who has tried to reposition the party as champions of the French language, but only succeeded in alienating trusty constituents. Still, the Liberals have a duty to try to clean up the mess they helped create. At least in admitting the error of their ways, they are helping open the door to a remedy.

The only solution is unanimous consent among all parties to withdraw the amendment before Bill 96 is voted on in its entirety. But of course the other teams aren’t eager to play ball. In fact, they’re rather enjoying watching their Liberal adversaries squirm like fish on a hook. After all, the Liberals’ self-inflicted misery could be their gain with an election around the corner.

Article content

Québec solidaire co-spokesperson Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois says his party quite likes the amendment, though believes it should be phased in slowly.

PQ language critic Pascal Bérubé would be a tougher sell. There’s no love lost between the PQ and anglos. And he certainly won’t be losing their votes if he refuses to come around.

Playing good cop, Legault said Wednesday he was open to discussing a retraction. After all, he has a special responsibility to try to untangle this Gordian knot as the self-appointed representative of anglophones in cabinet. But so much for a show of good faith: bad cop Jolin-Barrette indicated Wednesday there’s no going back.

Sadly, the political enjoyment of humiliating the Liberals is so great, and the prospect of undermining the interests of the English-speaking community so tempting, that it takes precedence over crafting sound policy or respecting expert advice.

Article content

These three additional courses in French (on top of the language courses they’re already required to take) were never supposed to be included in Bill 96. What urgency is there to mandate them now, other than petty partisanship?

Denying students the chance to reach their full potential would come with heavy personal, social and economic consequences. Are elected leaders really so cynical they would sacrifice the futures of young English-speaking Quebecers to score political points?

Ensuring more young English-speaking CEGEP students are able to pass college-level courses in French is a noble objective. But it can’t be reached overnight. And it certainly won’t be achieved through a haphazard amendment hatched during a committee hearing.

The message since Bill 96 was introduced is that anglophones are second-class citizens, that their rights don’t matter. On this one important point, it’s not too late to show English-speaking Quebecers — especially young ones — that they do count.

This is a plea to political leaders to do the right thing and withdraw the amendment.

[email protected]

Hanes: Tightening the screws on anglos, one clause at a time

Hanes: Axing the Dawson expansion is a low blow from Legault

Share this article in your social network

Comments

Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.

#model #modeling selected by Livio Acerbo – original source here